School-leavers are experts in using iPods and
the Internet but often cannot add up or follow basic instructions,
business leaders have claimed.
They said literacy and numeracy standards are so low that some
young recruits need remedial lessons.
The warning from the Confederation of British Industry casts
a shadow over the release on Thursday of what are expected to
be record GCSE results.
A survey for the business group showed that 52 per cent of
bosses think youngsters struggle to communicate and 50 per cent
say they cannot do simple sums.
One in seven employers said they had had to pay for training
to bring young staff up to scratch.
(Article continues below)
The CBI warned that the educational failings are jeopardising
the health of the economy.
Richard Lambert, the group's director-general, said: "Young
people are clearly doing some things very well.
"Their fluency with iPods, mobiles and MySpace has translated
well into the workplace, and often gives them an edge over their
bosses."
But he added: "Basic literacy and numeracy problems are
a nightmare for business and for individuals, so we have to
get these essentials right."
Professor Dylan Wiliam, of London's Institute of Education,
said GCSEs were stuck in the "19th century" because
they failed to push pupils to think critically.
Some 62.4 per cent of pupils gained a grade C or better at
GCSE last year and Thursday's results are expected to be even
better.
The CBI pointed out, however, that a minority of candidates
managed a good grade in both English and maths in 2006.
Further doubts about the exams emerged yesterday with news
that - in a shake-up scheduled for 2009 - pupils may be allowed
to retake parts of their courses as they go along.
Instead of results relying on exams at the end of two years
of study, courses would be split into separately-tested units.
Pupils would be able to be assessed on up to half of each GCSE
part-way through their studies and resit individual units if
their marks are disappointing. Assessed coursework would be
cut back.
Similar reforms to A-levels, in which candidates are allowed
unlimited resits, are said to have fuelled grade inflation.
In the first year of the new system, the A-level pass rate
jumped from 89.8 per cent to 94.3 per cent.
The Qualifications and Curriculum Authority, which is consulting
on the GCSE reforms, says it believes pupils should only have
one chance to resit a GCSE unit.
Any suspicion of "dumbing down" is likely to see
more schools abandon GCSEs and switch to tougher qualifications
such as the International GCSE.
Geoff Lucas, secretary of the Headmasters' and Headmistresses'
Conference of elite independent schools, said: "The experience
from A-levels ought to be heeded very carefully.
"It could well act as a further incentive for more independent
schools to take up the IGCSE."
Modular A-levels had "undoubtedly made it much easier
for students to reach the standard", he added.
Alan Smithers, professor of education at Buckingham University,
said: "The breaking up of the course can mean that pupils
may not have an integrated understanding of the subject.
"Modularising the GCSE is likely to increase overall results.
"This is partly because it will be easier for the individuals
to perform at a higher level through the restructuring of the
exam."
He added: "The retaking of units - even once - introduces
an element of unfairness."