"I would tell audiences that we were facing not a bubble
but a froth - lots of small, local bubbles that never grew to
a scale that could threaten the health of the overall economy."
Alan Greenspan, The Age of Turbulence.
That used to be Mr Greenspan's view of the US housing bubble.
He was wrong, alas. So how bad might this downturn get? To answer
this question we should ask a true bear. My favourite one is
Nouriel Roubini of New York University's Stern School of Business,
founder of RGE monitor.
Recently, Professor Roubini's scenarios have been dire enough
to make the flesh creep. But his thinking deserves to be taken
seriously. He first predicted a US recession in July 2006*.
At that time, his view was extremely controversial. It is so
no longer. Now he states that there is "a rising probability
of a 'catastrophic' financial and economic outcome"**.
The characteristics of this scenario are, he argues: "A
vicious circle where a deep recession makes the financial losses
more severe and where, in turn, large and growing financial
losses and a financial meltdown make the recession even more
severe."
Prof Roubini is even fonder of lists than I am. Here are his
12 - yes, 12 - steps to financial disaster.
(Article continues below)
Step one is the worst housing recession in US history. House
prices will, he says, fall by 20 to 30 per cent from their peak,
which would wipe out between $4,000bn and $6,000bn in household
wealth. Ten million households will end up with negative equity
and so with a huge incentive to put the house keys in the post
and depart for greener fields. Many more home-builders will
be bankrupted.
Step two would be further losses, beyond the $250bn-$300bn
now estimated, for subprime mortgages. About 60 per cent of
all mortgage origination between 2005 and 2007 had "reckless
or toxic features", argues Prof Roubini. Goldman Sachs
estimates mortgage losses at $400bn. But if home prices fell
by more than 20 per cent, losses would be bigger. That would
further impair the banks' ability to offer credit.
Step three would be big losses on unsecured consumer debt:
credit cards, auto loans, student loans and so forth. The "credit
crunch" would then spread from mortgages to a wide range
of consumer credit.
Step four would be the downgrading of the monoline insurers,
which do not deserve the AAA rating on which their business
depends. A further $150bn writedown of asset-backed securities
would then ensue.
Step five would be the meltdown of the commercial property
market, while step six would be bankruptcy of a large regional
or national bank.
Full
article here.