Thirty-seven years ago, in the midst of a bitter-cold Michigan
winter, 109 Vietnam veterans gathered at a Howard Johnson
Motel auditorium in Detroit to tell their stories. For three
days, they told of ransacking undefended villages, attacking
civilians, mutilating bodies, torturing Viet Cong suspects,
burning houses, destroying Vietnamese property and livestock
and killing innocent children. At the conference, entitled
Winter Soldier, the veterans accepted responsibility and mourned
for their actions. But, taken collectively, their words incriminated
a much larger culprit: the war itself.
This year, from March 13 to 16, about 300 veterans of the
wars in Iraq and Afghanistan will follow in the footsteps
of their predecessors, gathering for a second Winter Soldier
conference, in Silver Spring, Maryland. Organized by Iraq
Veterans Against the War (IVAW) it will make up the largest
gathering ever of Iraq and Afghanistan veterans.
Their mission? To tell the story of the war in the terms
of those who have actually lived it.
(Article continues below)
"This is a moment when veterans won't let anyone else
speak for us," said Aaron Hughes, an Iraq veteran who
initiated the new Winter Soldier effort. "We hear from
the pundits, we hear from the politicians, we hear from the
generals, but we don't hear from the soldiers who've walked
the streets, who've been there and know what it's about. We're
the ones who can bring out the cruelties and dehumanization
in US foreign policy."
The event, which will accommodate about 700 veteran advocates,
social workers, support staff and members of the media in
addition to veterans, will combine soldier testimonies and
expert panels. The panels are intended to provide a factual
context for the personal stories, according to Perry O'Brien,
one of Winter Soldier's organizers. Panels and testimony will
be grouped into 12 categories, including killing and wounding
noncombatants, mishandling of dead, torture and abuse, sexual
assault, discrimination in the military, destruction of civilian
property, veterans' benefits issues and GI resistance.
Some testimonies will address acts of large-scale violence
and human rights violations, while others will zero in on
incidents that are often overlooked, such as racism toward
Iraqis, sexual harassment of civilians and the military's
waste and destruction of environmental resources.
O'Brien hopes that, through the medium of veterans' firsthand
accounts, the public will gain new insight into the concrete
abuses perpetuated by what may seem to be abstract foreign
policy decisions.
"More than just telling stories, our goal is to show
what's going on in both countries that is a result of US military
policies," O'Brien said. "When we say, 'this is
what we saw, this is what we were ordered to do,' patterns
emerge. The patterns show that what the US is doing in Iraq
is immoral and in many cases illegal."
IVAW has always turned to Vietnam veterans for mentorship
and support, according to O'Brien, and the second Winter Soldier
will echo its predecessor in its mission and basic themes.
But this Winter Soldier's content will be, in many ways, very
different. With digital recording technology at their disposal,
soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan have been able to capture
the war through a variety of media. Photos and video footage
- in addition to stories and speeches - will make up a key
part of the program.
New technologies also mean a wider reach for this Winter
Soldier: the event will be broadcast in its entirety on satellite
channels, and live streaming coverage will be available at
IVAW's web site.
With a wider reach comes the possibility of backlash. The
first Winter Soldier met with a groundswell of criticism,
including accusations that the testimonies were untrue or
deceitful. This time around, though, IVAW will leave little
room for critics to attempt to invalidate their stories. A
20-member verification team, made up mostly of combat soldiers,
is collecting and vetting all the testimony before it is presented.
"Among the far right-wing fringe we'll be accused of
being 'phony soldiers,' and there will probably be accusations
of false testimony," O'Brien said. "But we're confident
that the case we'll be making is very credible."
Jose Vasquez, an Army reservist who refused to serve in
Iraq and Afghanistan, has been working for months on the verification
team. The meticulous process starts with interviews, basic
background checks and questionnaires, then moves on to incident
reports and photos. Vasquez speaks with other soldiers in
each would-be testifier's unit, looking for corroboration.
The team is also working with the National Lawyers Guild to
put together Freedom of Information Act requests about operations
in Iraq, and with Iraqi translators on the ground who can
sometimes find civilians to corroborate accounts of particular
events.
Vasquez holds that only testimonies that hold up to the
most meticulous scrutiny will be presented.
"The ones we feel shaky about, we won't include in
the public panel," he said.
The investigations behind the testimonies don't just lend
the conference more credibility; Winter Soldier's organizers
are determined to give their testifiers' words staying power.
A compilation of their stories will be released in September
or October, co-written by unembedded reporter Aaron Glantz,
author of "How America Lost Iraq."
Also, according to Hughes, vets will come away from the
conference with "truth in recruiting" materials,
so they can more actively educate potential military recruits
in their areas. Additionally, legal experts at the conference
will give vets a more accurate sense of their own rights and
the benefits they are entitled to, so they can better advocate
for themselves.
Hughes sees the conference not as a stand-alone protest,
but as a beginning.
"There's a whole tradition we're really trying to awaken,
of US soldiers coming back from wars and resisting,"
he said. "We're trying to perpetuate that and make sure
that when the government goes on military ventures for profit,
the veterans are going to resist. We want to make sure it's
a tradition that's being carried through."