Compelled to take up arms to regain their liberties as
Englishmen, America's Founders knew that even the constitutional
republic they had established could threaten the freedoms
for which they had fought. In the First Amendment, they
established a first line of defense — the freedoms
of religion, speech, press, assembly and petition.
Knowing that words and parchment barriers alone would prove
inadequate to restrain those elected as servants from becoming
tyrants, they added the Second Amendment to secure "the
right of the people to keep and bear Arms" —
not to protect deer hunters and skeet shooters, but to guarantee
to themselves and their posterity the blessings of "a
free State."
Their foremost concern was the precipitating events of
the American Revolution, wherein British troops in Massachusetts
and Virginia seized American muskets, cannon and powder
— actions the Declaration of Independence calls "a
design to reduce (the colonists) under absolute Despotism."
(Article continues below)
Entrusting the nation's sovereignty to the people, the
amendment breaks the government's military monopoly, guaranteeing
to the people such firearms as would be necessary to defend
against the sort of government abuse of their inalienable
rights the British had committed.
Thus, the amendment's "well regulated Militia"
encompasses all citizens who constitute the polity of the
nation with the right to form their own government. The
amendment's "keep and bear Arms" secures the right
to possess firearms such as fully-automatic rifles, which
are both the "lineal descendant(s) of … founding-era
weapon(s)" (applying a 2007 court of appeals' test),
and "ordinary military equipment" (applying a
1939 Supreme Court standard).
No government deprives its citizens of rights without asserting
that its actions are "reasonable" and "necessary"
for high-sounding reasons such as "public safety."
A right that can be regulated is no right at all, only a
temporary privilege dependent upon the good will of the
very government officials that such right is designed to
constrain.
Herbert W. Titus and William J. Olson are attorneys
for Gun Owners of America, which filed a brief in the Second
Amendment case the Supreme Court heard Tuesday.