Former Undersecretary of Defense for Policy Douglas J. Feith,
who was at the heart of the Bush administration's selective
cherry-picking of intelligence to make its case for the invasion
of Iraq, appeared on The Daily Show on Monday to promote his
new book about the run-up to the war.
The central premise of Feith's book, which he repeated over
and over to Jon Stewart, is that although there were errors
in some of the administration's claims about the dangers posed
by Saddam Hussein, the people making those statements were
not being intentionally dishonest and did not set out to mislead
the American public.
"The administration had an honest belief in the things
that it said," Feith insisted. "Some of the things
that it said about the war that were part of the rationale
for the war were wrong. But errors are not lies and I think
much of what the administration said was correct and provided
an important argument that leaving Saddam Hussein in power
would have been extremely risky -- even though the president's
decision to remove him was extremely risky."
(Article continues below)
Stewart pointed out in response that painting a rosy picture
of how quick and easy the war would be while downplaying the
risks was itself a form of dishonesty. "You said something
that I thought was interesting," he noted to Feith. "'The
common refrain that the postwar has been a disaster is only
true if you had completely unrealistic expectations.' Where
would we have gotten those expectations?"
"If you knew the perils but the conversation that you
had with the public painted a rosier picture, how is that
not deception?" Stewart asked.
Feith attempted to counter this by suggesting that because
"the recent history has been very unhappy in a lot of
ways ... people look back and I think they misremember a lot,"
but he finally resorted to claiming once more that "there
were statements ... that in looking back you wish you would
have made differently ... I don't think any of them were deception.
I think they were errors."
"You don't think it was a purposeful strategy?"
Stewart asked. "This is an administration very sophisticated
in the arts of propaganda and public relations."
Feith insisted that far from being sophisticated, the administration
was actually very bad at propaganda. He then went on to summarize
his version of what led up to the war:
"What the president decided after 9/11 was we should
not focus only on the group that hit us, we should be trying
to prevent the next attack. ... The administration ... became
persuaded by the facts that Saddam Hussein was an extremely
serious danger. ... There was a moment when the president
wanted to focus on diplomacy. ... Ultimately the diplomacy
failed. ... The administration grossly mishandled the public
explanation."
"You removed the ability for the American public to
make an informed decision," responded Stewart. "Once
you have removed that, then you no longer have, I think, the
authority."
This video is from Comedy Central's The Daily Show, broadcast
May 12, 2008.